In October of 2002, I investigated the historic Smalley’s tavern and restaurant in Carmel, New York. On my first visit, the investigation was broadcast live on the Woodman show on K104 radio. There were three members of the station with us, as well as several reporters and a photographer. That day we found more than we bargained for—or should I say they found us…
When I returned a few days later, a television crew captured more bizarre phenomena. The following is just a taste of what happens at this very haunted old restaurant.
…We decided to investigate the meat locker where the busboy had been trapped. I opened the door, and tried to take a step forward, but was jerked to a stop. Someone had a hold of my coat and I couldn’t move.
For god’s sake, I thought, more than a bit exasperated, I know these people are scared, but they’re all adults. Did someone really have to grab hold of my coat like a little kid?
In a way, I couldn’t have been more right, although I didn’t know it at that moment.
I asked who was holding me, and everyone replied that no one was even touching me. I then thought that my coat must have gotten caught on some type of hook, but in the darkness I ran my hand up and down the smooth wood frame and found that not a single hook or latch was there. There was simply nothing on which to get caught.
Then I decided I had better take a step back, and I was suddenly released from whatever had gripped me. Sandy Tomcho, one of the reporters from the Times Herald Record, was directly behind me, and she said that even though it was very dimly lit, she had clearly seen my coat sticking out straight behind me, but she couldn’t see anything holding onto it! Tony turned on the lights, and we could not find any reason for my coat to have refused to follow me into the meat locker. Could this have been the spirit of little Elizabeth Smalley, who has been known to literally grab people’s attention?
Just a few days earlier, I had given a lecture and someone asked if I had ever been physically in the grasp of an entity, and I had said no. That night after visiting Smalley’s, I had another lecture and was asked the same question. This time I couldn’t say no.
As startling as this "death grip" was, I didn’t have time to ponder its implications. We moved back to the infamous basement staircase, and weren’t disappointed. Those very heavy footsteps passed directly overhead once again. I can’t emphasize enough how clear they were. It wasn’t as if there was some vague creaking of floorboards somewhere—these were unmistakable footsteps directly on the floor above us. No questions, no doubts.
This time, however, we had an extra bonus—whoever it was, walked right to a door near the top of the stairs and pounded on something. Tony knew exactly what it was, a massive lion head knocker that hung there. Again, there was no mistaking the metallic banging sound of the knocker on that wooden door. These were such amazing phenomena I almost asked someone to pinch me to see if I was dreaming, but I quickly decided I had enough physical contact for the day…
These doors are at the top of the stairs where we heard the heavy footsteps and banging sounds. At one point, these doors opened by themselves. The bright spots on the gray part of the doors cannot be reflections—that is gray fabric, which couldn’t possibly reflect light.